Journal of Reproduction & Infertility

Journal of Reproduction & Infertility

Designing an ELISA method using sperm surface antigens for detection of antisperm antibody in comparison with SpermMar test

Authors
Asghar Talebian 1
Amir Hassan Zarnani 2
Mahmood Jeddi-Tehrani 2
Mohammad Mehdi Akhondi 1
Mahmoud Jalali 3
Mohammad Reza Sadeghi 1
1 Reproductive Biotechnology Research Center, Avicenna Research Institute, ACECR, Tehran, Iran
2 Monoclonal Antibody Research Center, Avicenna Research Institute (ACECR), Tehran, Iran
3 Human Nutrition and Biochemistry Department, Faculty of Public Health, Tehran Medical Sciences University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Introduction: The role of antisperm antibodies with a prevalence of 6-26% is well known in immunological infertility. Thus, there is clinical importance to determine ASA levels in both male and female. Nowadays, one of the most important discussed controversies in the field of immunological infertility is establishing an standard method to determine ASA. It seems that ELISA method will be more sensitive, specific and more diagnostic in determination of ASA if sperm surface antigens could be used as coated antigens, with least contamination to sperm intracellular antigens and nonspermic antigens. So, the aim of this study is designing an ELISA method by using the best method of sperm antigens extraction with at least contamination. Materials and Methods: In this study we designed an ELISA method with three different extraction methods of sperm antigens including sonication method, using SDS detergent, and application of LIS detergent, then we compared ELISA method based on the three extraction methods as well as two similar commercial ELISA kit (IBL Co, and Bioserv Co) with SpermMar test. Results: Comparing designed method with commercial kit indicated that among 28 sera which had 16 positive sera and 12 negative sera by SpermMar, 14 sera were true positive by LIS method and only 2 cases were false negative without any false positive results, whereas there were 5 true positive results and 11 cases false negative by the sonication method. The SDS method also had 13 true positive results with 3 false negative and 4 false positive results. In addition, two commercial kit had in turn 7 and 4 cases true positive and both of them had 1 case false positive and in turn 9 and 12 cases with false negative result. ELISA method designed by LIS detergent has adequate sensitivity (87.5%) with higher specificity (100%) and efficacy (92.8 %) than other extraction methods. There is a significant correlation between this designed method and SpermMar test (r=0.572). Conclusion: The results of this study indicated that ELISA method by LIS antigens has at least contamination with nonspermic antigens and it is better than other extraction methods and commercial ELISA kits for detection of antisperm antibody.
Keywords
Antisperm antibody
ELISA
Infertility
LIS
Sperm
Sperm surface antigens
SpermMar
Landsteiner K., Zur kenntnis der spezifisch auf Blutkor-Perchen wirkende sera. Zentralbl Bakeriol.1899;25:546.
Lit.S. Sperm immunology. Infertility and fertility Control. Obstet Gynecol.1974;44:607-23.
Rumke P., Hellinga G. Autoantibodies against spermatozoa in sterile men. Am J Clin Pathol. 1959; 32:357.
Mazumdar S., Levine A. S. AntiSperm anti- bodies: etiology, Pathogenesis, diagnosis, and treatment. Fertil Steril.1998;70(5):799-810.
Haas G.G., Jr., Cines D.B., Schreiber A.D. Immunologic infertility: identification of patients with antisperm antibodies. N Engl J Med.1980; 303:722-70.
Tsuji Y., Clausen H., Nudelman E., Kaizu T., Hakomori S.I., Isojima S. Human sperm carbo- hydrate antigen defined by an antisperm human monoclonal antibody drived from an infertile woman bearing antisperm antibodies in herserum. J Exp Med.1988;168:343-356.
Check J.H., Ardelson H.G., Bollendorf A. Effect of antisperm antibodies on computerized semen analysis. Arch Androl.1991;27:61-63.
Pattinson H.A., Mortimer D. Prevalence of sperm surface antibodies in the male partners of infertile couples as determined by immunobead screening. Fertil Steril.1987;48:466-9.
Witkin S.S. Sperm– reactive antibodies as measured by enzyme linked immunosorbent assay. In: Mathur S., Fredricks C.M., (Editors). Perspectives in immunoreproduction: conception and contraception. Washington, Hemisphere Publishing Company.1988.
Heidenreich A., Bonfig R., Wilbert D.M., Strohmaier W.L., Engelmann U.H. Risk factor for antisperm antibodies in infertile men. Am J Reprod Immunol.1994;31:69-76.
Gilbert B.R., Witkin S.S., Goldstein M. Immunology of male infertility. AUA Update. 1990.
Bates C.A., Antisperm antibodies and male subfertility. Br J Urol.1997;80:691-7.
Dondero F., Gandini L., Lombardo F., Sala- cone P., Caponecchia L., Lenzi A. Antisperm antibody detection 1: methods and standard protocol. Am J Repod Immunol.1997;38:218-223.
Mandelbaum S.L., Diamon M.P., Decherney A.H., The impact of antisperm antibodies on human infertility. J Urol.1987;138:1-8.
Alexander N.J., Bearwood D. An immuno- sorption assay for antibodies to spermatozoa comparison with agglutination and immuno- bilization tests. Fertil Steril.1984;41 (2):270-76.
Alexander J.S., Galle P.C., Hass G.Gjr. Detection and titration of calss specific antisperm antibodies in serum using and enzyme-linked immunosorvent assay. Obster Gynecol. 1988; 71(5):681.
Windt M.L., Bouic P.J.D., Lombard C.J., Menkveld R., Kruger T.F. Antisperm antibody tests: Traditional methods compared to ELISA. Arch Androl.1989;23:139-145.
Francavilla F., Romano R., Santucci R., Verghetta G La., Abrizio P.D., Francavilla S. Naturally occurring antisperm antibodies in men: interference with fertility and implication for treatment. Front Biosci.1999;4:25.
Dondero F., Lombardo F., Gandini L., Lenzi A. Antisperm antibody detection: method and standard protocol. Androl.1999;31:305-308.
Lynch D.M., Howe S.E. Comparison of a direct and indirect ELISA for quantitating anti- sperm antibody in semen. J Androl.1987:8:215-220.
Rumke P. The presence of sperm antibodies in the serum of two patients with oligospermia. Vox Sang.4.1954;135-40.
Wilson L. Sperm agglutinins in human semen and blood. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med.1954;85:652-55.
Bohring C., Krause E., Habermann B., Krause W. Isolation and identification of sperm membrane antigens recognized by antisperm antibodies and their possible role in immunological infertility disease. Mol Hum Reprod.2001;7(2):113-118.
Benet-Rubnat J.M., Martinez P.,Lepp W.A.,Egozcue J. Detection of induced antisperm anti-bodies by an improved Enzyme-linked immuno-sorbent assay. Int J Fertil.1991;36(1):48-56.
Saji F., Ohashi K., Kato M., Negro T., Tanizawa O. Clinical evaluation of the enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kit for anti-sperm antibodies. Fertil Steril.1988;50:644-47.
Bohring C., Krause W. The characterization of human spermatozoa membrane proteins-surface antigens and immunological infertility. Electro- Phoresis.1999;20:1-5.
Jeyendran R.S., Van der Ven H.H., Perez-Pelaez M., Crabo BG., Zaneveld L.J.D. Develp-ment of an assay to asess the functional intergrity of the human sperm membrane and its relationship to other semen characteristics.J Reprod Fertil.1984; 70:29-228.
Iborra A., Morte C., Fuentes P., Garcia-Framis V., Andolz P., Martinez P. Human sperm coating antigen from seminal plasma origin. Am J Reprod. Immunol.1996;36:118-125.
Baukloh V., Mettler L. Enzyme-linked Immu-nosorbent assay for sperm antibody detection and antigen analysis. J Immunol Methods.1983;56: 193-199.
Lenzi A., Gandini L., Lombardo F., Rago R., Paoli D., Dondero F. Antisperm antibodies detec- tion 2. Clinical, Biological and statistical correla- tion between methods. Am J Reprod Immunol. 1997;38:224-230.
Kurpisz M., Dobratz B., Alexander N.J. Sperm antigen and reactivity of antisperm monoclonal antibodies in ELISA. Androl.1993;25:175-79.
Reilly B.D., Goldberg E.H. Evaluation of a solid phase celluar enzyme immunoassay for detection of the serologically defined male antigen. J Immunol Methods.1991;142:121-126.
Crowther J.R. ELISA (theory and practice), 42. Mothod in molecular biology. Walker J.M (Series Editor).1995.
Engvall E., Perlmann P. Enzyme- linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Quantitative assay of immunoglobulin G. Immunochemistry. 1971;8:871-875.
Journal of Reproduction & Infertility
Volume 5, Issue 1
Winter 2004
Pages 23-34