Journal of Reproduction & Infertility

Journal of Reproduction & Infertility

Issuing Birth Certificates and ID Cards for Newborns Following a Surrogate Birth and the Legal and Ethical Responsibilities of the Medical Team

Authors
Ali Reza Milanifar 1
Mohammad Mehdi Akhondi 1
Zohreh Behjati Ardakani 2
Azadeh Abdolahzadeh 1
1 Reproductive Biotechnology Research Center, Avicenna Research Institute, ACECR, Tehran, Iran
2 Avicenna Infertility Clinic, Avicenna Research Institute (ACECR), Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Infertility is known as one of the major problems that raises serious concerns due to its influence on social and family ties. Therefore, infertile couples have to resort to all methods of reproduction to overcome the problem. Surrogacy is considered one of the assisted reproductive techniques involving the third party and it is recommended to some infertile couples. According to the Iranian Civil Law, physicians are assigned to issue the birth certifi-cate for the offspring of the woman who has delivered it, while issuing unreal birth certificates will undoubtedly bring about penal fines. Applying surrogacy and issuing birth certificates makes the law turn a blind eye to the matter in certain cases which contradicts physicians’ assigned duties in this regard. Considering what was mentioned above and with regards to the current problems which emphasize the urgent amendment of the law, the authors try to introduce a short-term solution to the problem. In this approach, the birth certificate along with other documents is recorded by the executive medical team to be used to issue an ID card for the child regarding his or her biological parents.
Keywords
Birth Certificate
Civil Responsibility
ID card
Surrogate
  1. قانون ثبت احوال، روزنامه رسمی، شماره 9212، 23/5/1355 و روزنامه رسمی شماره 11633، 10/11/1363.
  2. جلالیان محمدتقی. صحت قرارداد استفاده از رحم جایگزین. رحم جایگزین (مجموعه مقالات)، سمت، 1386، صفحات: 360-321.
  3. قاسم زاده مرتضی. اجاره رحم در حقوق ایران. رحم جایگزین (مجموعه مقالات)، سمت، 1386، صفحات: 53-437.
  4. قانون مدنی، جلد دوم، مصوب 1313و 1314، دوره نهم، چاپخانه مجلس شورا، صفحات: 215-100.
  5. کاتوزیان ناصر. حقوق خانواده.نشر دادگستر،صفحه: 342، شماره 248.
  6. بختیاری مریم. رحم جایگزین تجربه مادر و زوجین درخواست کننده. رحم جایگزین (مجموعه مقالات)، سمت، 1386، صفحات:
  7. IVF, Surrogacy law reform released. Produced by the commission and appeared in the July 2007 issue of the law Institute Journal. http://www. lawreform.vic.gov. au/wps/wcm/connect/Law+Reform/Home/Newsroom/Media+Coverage/LAWREFORM+-+IVF,+surrogacy+ law+reform+released+-+July+07
  8. Tomas M. Pinkerton Esq. /CA surrogacy law/Feb.2005 www.surrogacy.com/jri_articles/.
  9. http://www.surrogacy.com/legals/article/palaw.html.
  10. Illinois Department of Public Health http://www.idph. state.Il.us/vitalrecords/surrogateinfo. htm
  11. Registering the birth of a child conceived after fertility treatment. Northamptonshirecounty council.http://www northampton shire.gov.uk/community/ registration/ register_birth. Htm#Registering.
  12. Surrogacy provisions. http://www.infertilityanswers. Net/Surrogacy__state_by_state
Journal of Reproduction & Infertility
Volume 9, Issue 1
Spring 2008
Pages 82-88